Is coil whine normal on a gtx 970?

Permalänk

Is coil whine normal on a gtx 970?

Hello!
Last year I went through 3 gtx 970s and ALL of them had coil whine, so I returned them.
Anyways, I'm wondering if this is on all 970 or if it's a common issue. Has it been resolved?
I've saved some money now and I'm on a hunt for a graphics card, and currently there's only one option, the 970.
I'm going to wait if this is still common.

Permalänk
Medlem

Personally I don't have coilwhine on my Zotac 970.

Permalänk

@Friterad: Did you purchase it recently?

Permalänk
Medlem

I'd say that coil whine on ANY modern card today is pretty common. Usually, the higher number of frames and/or combined with load is what will make it squeal like a pig. Some cards are worse than others but in general I think that all cards comes with more or less coil whine today, AMD as Nvidia.

Visa signatur

..:: trickeh2k ::..
Windows 11 Pro - Ryzen 7 7800X3D - ASUS TUF B650-PLUS - Kingston FURY Beast DDR5 64GB CL36 - MSI MAG A850GL - MSI RTX 4080 VENTUS 3X OC - Acer Predator XB271HU - ASUS VG248QE - QPAD MK-85 (MX-Brown)/Logitech G PRO Wireless - Samsung 960 EVO 250GB, Samsung EVO 860 500GB, SanDisk Ultra II 480GB, Crucial MX500 1TB, Kingston KC3000 2TB - Steelseries Arctic 5 - Cooler Master Masterbox TD500 Mesh V2

Permalänk
Medlem

Yes is is very common issue many GTX 970 owners have coilwhine. Also it depends on what hardware people have. Some don't have it.

Also coilwhine can come from bad quality PSU i mean power supply.
I had coilwhine with my GTX 760 when i had PSU "Corsair 520HX " and when i did buy a better quality psu "Seasonic Platinum 660W" i had no more coilwhine .

Permalänk
Medlem

I'd say that most GPUs all more or less have coil whine. Sometimes you can only hear it when the GPU is rendering a huge number of frames per second though. Limiting the fps to something more reasonable often reduces the noise drastically.

Permalänk
Medlem

@Abdulla_Mehdi:
I had quite a lot of coil whine on my ASUS card. It also gave me a lot of interference on my sound card, making it output lots of weird noices in my headphones.

Permalänk
Medlem
Skrivet av Abdulla_Mehdi:

@Friterad: Did you purchase it recently?

In January

Permalänk
Avstängd
Skrivet av Friterad:

Personally I don't have coilwhine on my Zotac 970.

3dmark - cloudgate - no v-sync etc = no coilwhine?

Visa signatur

[I7 9700k] [Asus rog strix z390-f gaming] [2x8GB DDR4 3200MHz CL14 Flare X] [Msi rtx 2070 super gaming x trio] [Corsair RM850X 850W v2] [Samsung 970 EVO Plus 500GB
] [Noctua nh-d14] [Asus Xonar Essence STX] [fractal design define s] [Windows 10 pro x64]

Permalänk
Medlem

I guess people didn't read the first rule of this section of the forum. Ordinary discussion isn't allowed in this section. Keep them in other sections for example Grafikkort -> Geforce...

Visa signatur

Citera mig gärna så jag hittar tillbaka :-)

| CPU: I5 4670K | MB: Gigabyte Z97MX-Gaming 5 | RAM: Corsair 16GB VengeanceLP | GPU: Sapphire Rx570 mini med påmoddad Noctua NF-A12 | PSU: Corsair RM550x | Cpukylare: Noctua NH-L12 | Chassifläkt: Noctua NF-S12B | Chassi: Fractal Design Node 605 | SSD: Kingspec SSD M.2 256GB

Permalänk
Medlem
Skrivet av Abdulla_Mehdi:

@Friterad: Did you purchase it recently?

I've got one aswell, I bought it a couple of months ago and no coil whine yet *jinx*

Visa signatur

2600k @ STOCK <|> GTX 970 Omega!<|> Nån samsung 500gb ssd <|> 16 GB Kingston Hyper X <|> BenQ XL2420t
"Det finns inget skrot, bara gamla delar som kan användas på nya sätt" - Mulle Meck

Permalänk
Medlem

@Abdulla_Mehdi: What PSU do you have?

Permalänk
99:e percentilen

I tried four 970's (Asus Strix), all had serious coilwhine in Chrome and pretty much every single program that draws anything on-screen. Now I have a 980 with coilwhine only in games like Counter-Strike, but not only at high framerates.

I have tried different PSU's and even at a friend's place, so I feel pretty safe claiming that it was indeed the cards that were causing the whine.

Visa signatur

Skrivet med hjälp av Better SweClockers

Permalänk

@Aulo KY: Corsair CX750m

Permalänk
Medlem

I have an MSI Gaming GTX 970 purchased in December, I have not heard any coilwhine in any of the games I tried: Shadows of Mordor, Starcraft 2, Diablo 3, The Crew, The Witcher 3.

Visa signatur

Dator: AMD 5800X, ASUS RTX3060, 32GB RAM, Windows 10
Server: Intel NUC i5-4250U, 16GB RAM, Debian

Permalänk
Medlem

@Abdulla_Mehdi: It Might be the quality of the CX series that creates the coil whine. Usually the higher the ripple of a PSU is, the higher the chances are for coil whine in the GPU.

Permalänk
Medlem

Someone have found a fix for the coil whine in Menus. I have not test this, It may not work for everyone.

Go to Nvidias Control Panel. then to 3D Settings -> Manage 3D settings -> Global settings, and change "Vsync" to "Adaptive" and "Maximum pre-rendered frames" to 1.

This fix will limit fps in menus and remove the coil whine. let me know if it worked.

Permalänk
Avstängd
Skrivet av intel2000:

Someone have found a fix for the coil whine in Menus. I have not test this, It may not work for everyone.

Go to Nvidias Control Panel. then to 3D Settings -> Manage 3D settings -> Global settings, and change "Vsync" to "Adaptive" and "Maximum pre-rendered frames" to 1.

This fix will limit fps in menus and remove the coil whine. let me know if it worked.

Nice tips
I cant test it right now. If anyone can test like Grid 2 and Far cry 4 and see if the fps is locked in menus?

Visa signatur

[I7 9700k] [Asus rog strix z390-f gaming] [2x8GB DDR4 3200MHz CL14 Flare X] [Msi rtx 2070 super gaming x trio] [Corsair RM850X 850W v2] [Samsung 970 EVO Plus 500GB
] [Noctua nh-d14] [Asus Xonar Essence STX] [fractal design define s] [Windows 10 pro x64]

Permalänk
Avstängd
Skrivet av intel2000:

Someone have found a fix for the coil whine in Menus. I have not test this, It may not work for everyone.

Go to Nvidias Control Panel. then to 3D Settings -> Manage 3D settings -> Global settings, and change "Vsync" to "Adaptive" and "Maximum pre-rendered frames" to 1.

This fix will limit fps in menus and remove the coil whine. let me know if it worked.

Did not work, tested Grid 2 and the fps is just as high in menus.

Visa signatur

[I7 9700k] [Asus rog strix z390-f gaming] [2x8GB DDR4 3200MHz CL14 Flare X] [Msi rtx 2070 super gaming x trio] [Corsair RM850X 850W v2] [Samsung 970 EVO Plus 500GB
] [Noctua nh-d14] [Asus Xonar Essence STX] [fractal design define s] [Windows 10 pro x64]

Permalänk

As stated above, it's usually the PSU that causes coil whine.
Anyway, coil whine is reason enough to get your product(s) exchanged for new ones or your money back. At least in Sweden. Coil whine lessens the lifespan of electronical parts as the sound comes from coils vibrating and breaking earlier than they should.

Visa signatur

i9 10850K | MSI RTX3090 Ventus OC 24GB | MSI Tomahawk Z490 MAG | RM850x
Kingston HyperX DDR4 32GB 3600MHz CL18 | Samsung SSD 860 EVO 4TB
LG OLED 65CX / 55B7 | Philips BDM3270 monitor | PS4 Pro | Oculus Quest 2